Decision guides earn their keep by ordering the questions. NerdWallet's broker guides, including its five-step guide to switching brokers, put the steps in a sequence and attach a calculator to the money step. Switching is already covered on this blog, twice, so this page borrows the form for the earlier decision, choosing a broker in the first place, and checks every step against BrokerCompare's dataset of 50 US brokerages (verified September 15, 2026) instead of against impressions. Five steps, each with the count that settles it.
| Check | What the records show |
|---|---|
| 1. Trade price | Stock commission $0 at 36 of 41 recorded; options median $0.59 per contract |
| 2. Borrow price | Only 16 of 50 publish a base margin rate; the 16 run 4.90% to 12.45% |
| 3. Features | Fractional shares at 28, extended hours at 24, paper trading at 14 |
| 4. Protection | SIPC membership recorded at 44 of 50 |
| 5. Promotions | Only 4 of 50 record any signup bonus |
Steps 1 and 2: price the trade, then price the borrow
Trading first: stock commissions are $0 at 36 of the 41 brokers that record one, so the trade price that still separates brokers is the options contract fee, median $0.59, running from $0 at eight brokers to $1.00 at four. Borrowing second, because it is the step shoppers skip: only 16 of the 50 brokers publish a base margin rate in our records, and those run 4.90 to 12.45 percent. If you will never borrow, the step costs you nothing; if you might, a broker that will not state a rate has failed the step by silence.
Steps 3 and 4: count features, verify protection
Features are where marketing and records diverge, so count them: fractional shares at 28 of the 50, extended-hours trading at 24, paper trading at 14. Note which ones you will actually use, because a feature you never touch is not worth a fee you always pay. Protection is the non-negotiable step: SIPC membership is recorded at 44 of the 50. The six without it are mostly specialists rather than general brokerages, futures platforms NinjaTrader and Tradovate, TradeZero, the kids product Greenlight, Revolut US and Magnifi, which is context, not absolution; for a general investing account, treat the 44 as the shelf.
Step 5: discount the promotion
Last, and lightest: only 4 of the 50 brokers record any signup bonus in our data, Ally Invest at $200 on a $1,000 deposit, Betterment at $100 on $2,500, Stash at $25 on $5 and Greenlight at $50. A bonus is a one-time payment measured against years of fees and rates, and the records show how rare the real ones are; let it break a tie, never make the decision. Run the steps in order and the 50 narrow fast, usually to two or three names that the full comparison can separate field by field. If the outcome is a move, the SwitchCost Checker prices the switch itself. Sources: the modeled form is NerdWallet's five-step broker guide, applied to choosing rather than switching; all counts are from our dataset, as captioned.